My column for this month’s Tetbury Advertiser
Worn down by a bleak and hostile environment filled with threats, this month I turned to an old friend for comfort. No, I’m not talking about our current political climate, but about the final episode of the television series Sherlock.
Holmes regenerates in different guises more frequently than Dr Who, with over 200 films listed by IMDB. Although I loved the earlier episodes of the Cumberbatch incarnation, the finale left me cold. It was as if the cast had taken a wrong turning and ended up on the set of a James Bond villain’s lair. I craved the cosy retreat that is the centre of the world for the original Holmes and Watson: 221b Baker Street.
221b or Not 221b?
What a stroke of genius it was for Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to add the “b” to that address. With a single letter, he suggests the quirky subversiveness of a hero who makes up his own rules and isn’t afraid to stand up against the establishment – a true hero then and now.
These days the Sherlock Holmes Museum in Baker Street claims that door number as its own, but it’s actually just a plaque on the wall. The address is and always was fictitious, a Narnian wardrobe that many have sought but never found.
In times of trouble, whether personal, national or international, fictional characters and places can offer as much consolation as real ones, and often more. Sinking recently into the opening pages of Holmes’ first adventure, A Study in Scarlet, which I’d nominated as the BBC Radio Gloucestershire Book Club’s February Book of the Month, was like stepping into a hot bubble bath after running through a thunderstorm with neither raincoat nor umbrella. Elegant prose, cracking storytelling and engaging characters lured me into a world where there may still have been crime and hatred, but where there’s also the inevitability of resolution and the triumph of good over evil.
A Story for Our Times
Subtle moral lessons are woven in along the way. I’d forgotten that one of the themes of A Study in Scarlet is religious tolerance, the crime revolving around questionable acts by Mormons in nineteenth-century Utah. Over a century after publication, it’s a story still relevant to our times.
So if you’re troubled by the state of the world in 2017, Dr Watson would surely prescribe spending time in the company of the original “consulting detective”, Sherlock Holmes, as he first emerged from the pen of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.
Though you may feel, as I do, that if Benedict Cumberbatch appeared up on your doorstep, you wouldn’t turn him away. Alternative medicine, perhaps?
What’s your favourite comfort reading? I’d love to know!
Find more comfort in books and reading when you come along to the FREE Hawkesbury Upton Literature Festival on Saturday 22nd April 2017 in the delightful Cotswold village that I call home. I’m looking forward to unveiling my own mystery series there, Best Murder in Show. Come and join the fun!
6 thoughts on “Just What Dr Watson Ordered? – In Praise of the Original Sherlock Holmes and Comfort Reading”
I often turn to Laurie R. King’s Mary Russell series for a comfort read and coincidentally they feature The Great Detective too.
Ooh, I don’t know those, I’ll have to look them up. Thanks for the recommendation.
My comfort reading for the past 15 years has been the No1 Detective Agency series by Alexander McCall Smith. Although these witty, humane books deal with grief, AIDS, poverty and corruption in the Botswana setting, the heroine Precious Ramotswe has faith and hope.
Oh, I love those too, Bernadette – I went through the first six or seven in quick succession a year ago, and they were delightful. Good choice!
Thanks for this, Debbie. Comfort reading is a pretty good remedy in troubled times. Semolina for the soul, I always think.
That’s all very well unless you don’t happen to like semolina, like me! But that’s good advice coming from another medical doctor. 🙂 (Dr Carol Cooper includes a doctor and medical themes in her excellent novels, folks – I highly recommend “One Night at the Jacaranda” and its sequel “Hampstead Fever”.)